Fantasy Baseball: 2022 January Best Ball Review

With the slow draft starting on 30 January 2022, this was a very-early-preseason event for us all, and the first attempt at “Best Ball” for many of the participants.

The Format

16-team points league with the scoring structured to closely replicate roto, so you had to balance power and speed of the hitters, and maximise high-strikeout, low-ratio pitchers. We drafted 40 players each and these would be our roster for the entire season – no trades, no adds/drops, no replacing injured players.

The “Best Ball” aspect is automated by Fantrax. The best performance in each position by players on your roster is combined for the daily score. For instance, I had three first basemen on my roster: Brandon Belt, Miguel Sano, and Darin Ruf. If Belt scored three points, Sano one and Ruf didn’t play, my team would score three points at the first base slot. I didn’t have to decide which two to sit.

The scoring slots were catcher, first, second, third, short, three outfielders, DH, five starters and two relief slots. So ideally, you wanted at least two players in each position and plenty of pitchers.

David Runciman (my TGFBI/SWDL partner) had the first pick and took Fernando Tatis Jr.. Two months later, in a different league, David took Tatis Jr. again… but this time with the 108th pick. The dangers of early-season drafting are clear.

My first two picks were Bryce Harper and Walker Buehler, and then, bucking the habit of a lifetime, I took the trendy pick of catcher Salvador Perez in the third round. If there is a bandwagon, I will jump on it.

The first six rounds (detailed below) are a good reminder of our mindset before fantasy baseball draft prep had really kicked in.

After drafting Juan Soto with his first pick, Nick (LA Angels) went with five elite starters. As Nick’s pitching finished seventh out of 15 teams, it’s safe to suggest that this strategy failed.

Despite taking only one starter in the first six rounds, the roster with the best pitching was Adam’s (St Albans Wasps). He constructed a decent rotation (Corbin Burnes, Frankie Montas, Pablo Lopez, Jose Urquidy, Joe Ryan, Carlos Carrasco, and Jameson Taillon) and backed them up with three elite relievers (Josh Hader, Jordan Romano, and Devin Williams). Adam, who is consistently one of the most successful players I compete against, finished in a very impressive third position overall.

My team’s hitters scored 6699 points – not bad, good enough for fourth position. Only one team broke the 7000-point mark, Stefan ‘Bamos’ Appleby, who took Freddie Freeman and Yordan Alvarez on the turn with picks 16 and 17. His first pitcher was Max Fried (who went on to be the 2022 NL Cy Young runner-up) so it looked like the basis of a championship-winning team. Unfortunately, the rest of his pitching failed to make the grade and dragged him down to seventh overall.

STOP PRESS: During the offseason, Stefan’s book about non-league football was published. You should check it out.

Sixth overall was Aaron Ashby fanboy, Rob Noverraz. Rob took the much-hyped Brewers pitcher with his fifth pick; possibly the only surprise pick of the first 100. He was unlucky that his first-round pick, Shohei Ohtani, only scored points with his bat as, according to Fantrax, Ohtani’s only eligible position was outfield!

It should be noted that the slow draft with a one-hour clock worked better for some than others. The Fantrax queue system threw up lots of glitches over our 2022 draft season. It is possible that Rob did not intend to take Ashby ahead of his next two pitchers, Charlie Morton and Shane McClanahan.

My team finished fifth overall. Despite drafting three first basemen, it was a problem position for me all year. Remarkably, Miguel Sano finished on -24 points, MINUS 24. In fact, Albert Pujols‘ 394 points were more than my three first basemen combined. And Pujols wasn’t even drafted in this league!

Just ahead of me was Alex (AlexW12) who started with the excellent quartet of Jose Ramirez, Zack Wheeler, Aaron Nola, and Francisco Lindor. He might have done even better had he not lost John Means to injury after just two starts.

In round figures, players that scored more than 400 points were in the top 150. Despite 640 players being drafted, eight undrafted players broke into the top 150.

Players that failed to get into the Top 150 included Luis Robert, Whit Merrifield, and Jack Flaherty. I mention these three because the trio were taken in the first five picks by Ben Carter. It was difficult for his Team Chaos to recover from that start.

As previously mentioned, Adam was third overall but there was clear daylight between him and the top two teams. James Holden (BHP Early Doors) won the 2021 Bat Flips & Nerds Invitational and would go on to win the UK Invitational 2022, so without doubt he knows what he is doing. He finished fourth in pitching and third in hitting, which usually would be sufficient for the overall victory, but he was beaten by the sabermetric spreadsheet superiority of Russell Eassom.

Or was it karma? Jeers reverberated around the chat room when James drafted the pantomime villain of pitching, Trevor Bauer.

Russell, however, constructed a solid if uninspiring roster – Tyler Anderson was his best pitcher and Steven Kwan was one of his best hitters. They say that the key to winning fantasy baseball is maximising at-bats, and Russell not only enjoyed the most ABs but he also had Aaron Judge who scored 280 points more than the next-best player.



It is not easy to work out what I should do differently in 2023. There is a lot of luck involved in drafting this early, but as Russell won, you have to assume that there was more skill than luck.

Reducing risk probably makes sense. I had 10 players who either failed to play or scored fewer than 100 points; that’s one-quarter of my roster. Maybe I should draft the “All-Boring Roster”

Want to get involved with a Bat Flips & Nerds fantasy baseball league? Tell me about yourself in a Twitter DM @GavTramps

While we are on the subject of fantasy baseball, we have an opening for a fantasy baseball writer. If you fancy writing one or two articles a fortnight, click on the “write for us” link above.

And finally, check out our sister site Deep League Roto dedicated to fantasy baseball. It’s new and evolving… but it will get better.

Feature image of Fernando Tatis Jr. by Rob Leiter/MLB Photos via Getty Images

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.