Baseball… with a British twist

Kyle Tucker: Death, Taxes, and the Dodgers Signing the Best Players

Kyle Tucker representing Team USA in the 2023 WBC

Billionaire owners of the other 29 teams looked on sheepishly as the Dodgers added Kyle Tucker – the best available free agent – to their lineup. And man, what a lineup.

Shohei Ohtani
Mookie Betts
Freddie Freeman
Will Smith
Kyle Tucker
Teoscar Hernández
Max Muncy
Andy Pages
Tommy Edman

Tucker, who turns 29 this weekend, was the highest-profile free agent on the board, and his destination was never really about fit, weather, or vibes. It was about ambition. His ambition and the team’s. Once again, only one franchise acted like the window matters right now. So Tucker is a Dodger, because of course he is.

The four-year, $240 million deal is less about term than it is about intent. The opt-outs, the $64 million signing bonus, the record-setting AAV once taxes are applied – all of it screams immediacy. While much of the league treated this offseason like a risk-management seminar, the Dodgers saw it as a leverage opportunity. They didn’t wait for the market to cool. They detonated it.

There’s also a not-so-subtle labour subtext here. The extraordinarily high bonus and front-loaded cash strongly suggest the Dodgers are planning around a potential 2027 lockout. Pay now, secure elite talent, worry about the rest later. If baseball goes dark, Los Angeles will already have converted future uncertainty into present value — both on the field and on the balance sheet. And maybe, just maybe, they’ll have a three-peat tucked away too.

Kyle Tucker preparing to hit for the Chicago Cubs at Tokyo Dome
Photo by Daniel Shirey/MLB Photos via Getty Images

On the field, Tucker is exactly what this roster didn’t need but absolutely wanted: a left-handed, middle-of-the-order bat who does everything well and doesn’t have to carry the franchise. He slots into an already absurd lineup and raises the Dodgers’ margin for error from “significant” to “downright unfair.”

The rest of the league will complain about payroll disparity, deferred money, and competitive balance. But the real divide isn’t money – it’s will. The Dodgers are acting like championships are scarce and fleeting. Everyone else is acting like there’s always next year.

I went to a Cubs meet in the summer and none of the fans were impressed with Tucker. At least those fans can now take comfort in a compensatory draft pick instead of a 143 OPS+ Gold Glove right fielder.

With social media warriors calling for a boycott until caps and floors are introduced, it’s worth remembering that just a couple of months ago we watched one of the greatest postseasons ever.

We lived through the 2025 preseason of the Dodgers adding Roki Sasaki, Tanner Scott, Kirby Yates, Teoscar Hernández, and Blake Snell. Half the media crowned them champions in March, yet they finished with only the fifth-best record in baseball. It needed heroic hitting and chaotic comebacks in October to lift the Commissioner’s Trophy.

So yes, the Dodgers look like the only team trying to win, but baseball, conveniently, remains a funny old game.

Featured image of Kyle Tucker by Daniel Shirey

Picture of Gav, the article's author


Discover more from

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.